What is Pre Submission Feedback?
Pre submission feedback refers to the critical evaluation and suggestions provided by experts or peers before a research manuscript is submitted to a journal. This process is particularly valuable in the field of
cancer research, where studies often involve complex methodologies, advanced technologies, and significant implications for patient care.
It helps identify and address potential
methodological flaws.
It can enhance the clarity and impact of the research findings.
It increases the likelihood of
acceptance by the target journal.
It provides an opportunity to incorporate the latest
scientific advancements.
Key Questions to Address During Pre Submission Feedback
Feedback should focus on several key questions:1. Is the Research Question Clearly Defined?
The research question must be clearly articulated. It should address a significant gap in the current understanding of
cancer biology or treatment.
2. Are the Methods Appropriate?
Evaluate whether the study design, sample size, and statistical analyses are appropriate for the research question. Are the methods described in sufficient detail to allow replication?
3. Are the Results Robust and Reproducible?
Assess the robustness of the results. Are the findings consistent with existing literature? Are there any
confounding factors or biases?
4. Is the Discussion Comprehensive?
Ensure that the discussion section adequately addresses the implications of the findings, limitations of the study, and potential future directions. Does it place the results in the context of current
cancer research?
5. Is the Manuscript Well-Written?
The manuscript should be clear, concise, and free of grammatical errors. It should follow the target journal's guidelines for formatting and structure.
Review all comments carefully and consider the merit of each suggestion.
Revise the manuscript to address the feedback, making changes to the methodology, results, or discussion as needed.
Provide a response to each point of feedback, explaining how it was addressed or why it was not incorporated.
Conclusion
Pre submission feedback is a critical step in the preparation of a cancer research manuscript. By seeking input from experts and peers, researchers can significantly improve the quality and impact of their work. This process not only enhances the likelihood of acceptance by high-impact journals but also contributes to the advancement of cancer research and patient care.
